Wow. So that was X-Men 3: The Last Stand. And this is my review.
To start with, when it comes to the X-Men, I’m your worst nightmare. I can barely remember my middle name most of the time, but I could probably tell you the content of every single one of Chris Claremont’s original run on Uncanny X-Men. I still remember a lot of events in my life by what issue of X-Men I bought that day. Seriously, some scary shit. So, I was really pretty delighted with the way Bryan Singer handled the first two X-films (that’s films, to the X-Treme! SNIKT SNIKT! BAMF!).
I’m going to warn you up front– Matthew is going to disagree with me on this, so I’m going to make an effort to write an intelligent, mature review. So I’d like to start out by saying “THPPPPT!!!!” to Brett Ratner.
X3 could have been a decent film. It was rushed to market in an apparent effort to beat DC comics new Superman film (helmed, oddly enough, by Bryan Singer) to market. And it shows. The script needed a big old polish– the dialogue was piss-poor and the plot lacked subtlety. Things happened, just so they could happen.
Okay, now on to the spoiler portion of this. So, if you intend to see this film, and want to be surprised by what’s coming, don’t read any more.
If you consider the X films to be a trilogy, then I actually applaud the balls that Marvel had to kill off some major players (sort of) in the X-Men pantheon. Cyclops death at the hands of Jean Grey should have a GREAT deal of emotional resonance, yet they barely even touched on what impact that had on her character, much less on the rest of the X-Men.
The death of Prof. X was one of the more emotional points of the film to me, and I actually think it was probably the high point of the whole thing. I just wish they had capitalized on it a little more.
So, that’s the positive part of my review. Now on to the rest. Remember how I said that the movie was rushed to market? Well, it shows. A great example is a scene where Magneto has just ripped the Golden Gate Bridge in half and used it to go from the mainland to Alcatraz so that his mutant army can cross and get to the Maguffin. It’s broad day-light. In the VERY NEXT CUT, it is full night. No indication of anything having held up the mutant army crossing the bridge. Nope, it’s just night-time. So, in an effort to help “bridge” this continuity gap for our loyal readers, I’d like to propose the following scene for the Director’s Cut:
MAGNETO (to Phoenix): You know what? These X-Men have kind of fucked with us in the last couple of films. Let’s do something to mess ‘em up just a little.
PHOENIX: How about… you know, in the comics, I ate a sun orbitted by a planet populated with people that look like broccoli, so how about I…
MAGNETO: Jesus Christ, woman. Just make it night or something. Wolverine will piss himself. The best at what he does, my ass.
PHOENIX (grumbling to self): I knew I should have stayed dead. I got better treatment from Chuck Austen.
Awwwww… sweet continuity editing.
On to other things: a number of friends geekier than I (I’m looking at you, Ho) have pointed out some differences between the comic and the film. Such as Juggernaut isn’t a mutant in the comic. Leech should actually be a GREEN bald kid with little lighter green warts all over his head and a pink buddy who can’t talk but projects his thoughts as pictures in the comic, and is just a bald kid in the movie. Or that… wait a minute. I think we have bigger problems than all that. Like the dialogue for example. Pretty heavyhanded, you say? Who am I to disagree, old friend?
And the music? Usually, I only take note of good music, and mediocre music just washes over me and I forget it before the movie is even over. Surprisingly, this really stuck with me. It was baaaaaaad. If you have any questions, reference the scene where Angel flies away after leaving daddy-dearest’s evil clutches. I’m not actually entirely sure why Angel was in this movie. It kind of felt like fluff.
Ok. I’m done ranting now. Matthew, please bring a counter-point to the table. Anyone who has seen the film besides myself, please chime in. Dave, be funny. Kelli, pretend you’ve seen it, and make something up.
The End…Or is it?
That’s right, stick around after the credits and you’ll see the most gratuitous little piece of film that’s been around in a while. Remember where I said that killing Prof. X was the most emotionally resonant bit in the film. Well, I guess not. Or is it…?